Comparison at different profit levels
| Profit | Sole trader | Limited company | Better by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Enter your numbers above to see this table. | |||
From April 2026, dividend tax rose to 10.75% (basic rate) and 35.75% (higher rate), and employer National Insurance is 15% above £5,000. This has made a limited company less attractive for many people on modest profits than it used to be.
How to use this calculator
- Enter your yearly business profit before paying yourself.
- Choose a director's salary. Many directors take £12,570, the Personal Allowance. Our director's salary calculator compares the common choices side by side.
- Add the extra cost of running a company, such as higher accountancy fees, for a fair comparison.
How it's calculated
Worked example
Sam in England makes £60,000 profit, and would take a £12,570 salary if they set up a company.
At £60,000 the two are almost level: the sole trader comes out £20 ahead, before the extra costs of running a company.
When does a limited company start to pay off?
With 2026 to 2027 rates, if you take a £12,570 salary and pay out all the rest as dividends, the company almost never comes out ahead in this calculator. Between £20,000 and £200,000 of profit, it only wins in a narrow band around £60,200 to £60,500, by about £15 a year at most, and only if running the company costs nothing. Add £500 a year of running costs and the sole trader comes out ahead at every profit in that range.
| Profit | Sole trader keeps | Company director keeps | Sole trader ahead by |
|---|---|---|---|
| £30,000 | £25,468.20 | £24,403.45 | £1,064.75 |
| £40,000 | £32,868.20 | £31,632.70 | £1,235.50 |
| £50,000 | £40,268.20 | £38,861.95 | £1,406.25 |
| £60,000 | £46,111.40 | £46,091.20 | £20.20 |
| £80,000 | £57,711.40 | £55,764.87 | £1,946.53 |
| £100,000 | £69,311.40 | £65,209.62 | £4,101.78 |
| £150,000 | £92,040.40 | £85,109.90 | £6,930.50 |
England, Wales or Northern Ireland; £12,570 salary; all remaining profit paid out as dividends; no extra running costs. The gap is smallest around £60,000 because, at that profit, the dividends still mostly fall in the basic rate band while the sole trader is already paying 40% on part of their profit.
So why do people still use companies? Things this table leaves out can change the answer: keeping profit in the company instead of paying it all out (it's then taxed at Corporation Tax rates until you take it out), paying into a pension through the company, and non-tax reasons such as limited liability. Those depend on your plans, which is where an accountant helps.
The extra work and costs of running a company
Compare these with the tax difference above before deciding. As a company director, GOV.UK says you must:
- keep company records and prepare annual accounts
- file your accounts and a Company Tax Return, and pay Corporation Tax
- file a confirmation statement with Companies House, which has a fee
- register for PAYE and run payroll if the company pays someone £96 or more a week (a £12,570 salary is about £242 a week)
Many directors pay an accountant for some or all of this. Enter that cost in the "running costs" box above for a fair comparison. You also need to tell HMRC about dividends above your allowances, as GOV.UK explains on its tax on dividends page.
What this calculator doesn't cover
- Keeping profit in the company, pension contributions from the company, or paying a spouse.
- IR35, other income, student loans and the High Income Child Benefit Charge.
- Non-tax reasons for a company, such as limited liability or how clients see you.
Frequently asked questions
Why do directors take a £12,570 salary?
It uses the Personal Allowance, so there's no Income Tax on it, and it's below the employee NI threshold. The employer NI it costs is a deductible expense for the company. Some directors choose a lower salary; try different amounts above.
Is a limited company always better?
No. At many profit levels the difference is small, and running a company costs more in accountancy and admin. Talk to an accountant before changing your business structure.
Can I claim the Employment Allowance?
Not if you're a one-director company where the director is the only employee paid above the secondary threshold. That's why this calculator doesn't include it.
Sources (2026 to 2027): tax on dividends, Corporation Tax rates, employer rates and thresholds, Employment Allowance eligibility, running a limited company, confirmation statements, PAYE for employers.